Amanda Knox: Behind the Hollywood smile, a liar, a narcissist and a killer
By Tom Rawstorne
Created 1:21 AM on 05th December 2009
Then there would be the seven-figure media deals to be mulled over (with best-selling crime writer John Grisham pitching to pen the definitive book) and dates with Oprah Winfrey and Larry King to fulfil. There was even talk of a Hollywood film – after all, who could resist the story of a beautiful 22-year-old American whose trip to Italy ended with her being forced into confessing to a brutal murder that she did not commit?
But, as film goers know, Tinseltown loves a happy ending, and the guilty verdict delivered last night in the Aula degli Affreschi (Court of the Frescoes) put paid to that.
Taking aim: Amanda Knox poses with a gun
For Knox, her conviction for the murder of her British flatmate Meredith Kercher means an immediate return to Capanne prison on the outskirts of Perugia where she has spent much of the past two years.
She will be placed in a cell on her own and checked by guards every 15 minutes. If she is deemed not to be a suicide risk in all probability she will then be returned to the five-person cell she was in before.
There she had bagged one of the top bunks, so that she could see out of the window and to the world beyond.
Of course although Knox has been convicted, the judicial process is far from over. An appeal will be launched in the New Year, but that will not be heard until the autumn.
Amanda Knox: Her mother had planned a trip to a spa and a Mexican meal for her homecoming
Her divorced parents Edda Mellas and Curt Knox have remortgaged their homes, and so has Knox's 72-year-old German-born grandmother Elizabeth Huff .
They say that their credit cards are 'maxed out' and that they are now so short of money that they will have to sell their homes to continue their fight. Indeed, Mrs Mellas is seriously contemplating moving lock stock and barrel to Italy with her new husband to reduce the need for expensive transatlantic flights.
Mrs Mellas insists that she has never once doubted her daughter's innocence.
'Never,' she says. 'I'll do whatever it takes for Amanda, however long it takes. The good news is she will get out of this, the bad news it could take several more years.'
That she and her family are so sure of her innocence has at its essence a belief that Amanda Knox simply could not have murdered another human being.
'I'll tell you a little story about Amanda,' is the way Mrs Mellas explains it. 'She doesn't know how to lie. If you were to ask her, "What d'you think of my shoes?" and she thought they were hideous, she doesn't do the polite thing – she'll tell you they're hideous. Since she was five she'd do that.'
'We'll appeal': The parents of Amanda Knox have vowed to fight to free her
Indeed so good is her grasp of the language that her lawyer has suggested that she should herself go in to the law. While many will raise an eyebrow at such a suggestion it is entirely in keeping with the spin put on Knox's incarceration by her supporters.
They insist that she has tried to draw positives from her time inside, rather than wasting energy getting angry and resentful about the fate that has befallen her.
So it is we are told that she has whiled away the time by helping teach other inmates English and yoga and by learning to cook, to do needle-point and to play the classical guitar.
'She's made it a time to learn, to learn about herself and the friends she has and the way the world works,' says her mother. 'She realises it's not about her any more, she truly sees herself as one of the lucky ones in there.
'She sees women in there who have no support, or good lawyers, or even family, they have nothing.'
Such a depiction is central to the portrayal of Knox as herself a victim in this tragedy, the suggestion being that the way she has comported herself is indicative of her true character.
Since her arrest, any cracks that have emerged in that portrayal have time and time again been dismissed as being down to 'naivety' rather than anything more sinister.
For instance, at the police station prior her to arrest, why was Knox seen performing cartwheels?
'This is Amanda just being Amanda,' explains her mother. 'As her friends would say, "It's an Amanda thing". The police were still being friendly to her then, so she was stretching, and they were talking to her and she said, yes, she had been a gymnast, and they were like, "Well, how about a cartwheel?" so she did one.'
Shortly after that came Knox's confession, the one that put her squarely at the murder scene.
'It was coercion,' says her stepfather Chris Mellas, a 36-year-old IT professional who has spent many weeks at the trial supporting Knox.
'They (the Italian authorities) did what they needed to do to get her to say what they wanted her to say.'
Next they had to explain why she told police that Patrick Lumumba, an entirely innocent bar owner, was involved in the killing. Again, we are told, it was all down to police 'bullying', and that ever since Knox has felt 'terrible' about dragging him into it.
Jailed: Knox was sentenced to 26 years in prison
'That was for an assignment at university,' she says. 'Her friend Jessie had the same assignment, and she said Amanda's story is tame compared to hers.'
During the trial there were other slips, other quirks that caused surprise. Arriving at a hearing on Valentine's Day she wore a t-shirt bearing the slogan 'All You Need Is Love.'
On another occasion she interrupted proceedings to explain that a pink vibrator found amongst her belongings was a gift from a friend and was just 'a joke'.
Then there has been her see-sawing behaviour, smiles and flirty flirty glances followed soon after by tears and pained protestations of innocence. On its own, no one is saying that any of the above is indicative of guilt.
But taken with the prosecution's DNA evidence, it is easier to understand why the jury was willing to accept that Knox did indeed have it in her to carry out a brutal murder.
They clearly did not believe that Knox was an innocent abroad (the girl with the so-called 'acqua e sapone' face, the 'water and soap' representing wholesomeness and purity).
Rather, they chose to accept the version put forward by prosecutor Giuliano Mignini who describes the real Knox as being 'narcissistic, aggressive, manipulative, transgressive, with a tendency to dominate'.
Not only was she 'easily given to disliking people she disagreed with' but was a 'talented and calculating liar'.
On the night of the murder, the prosecution alleged, Knox and Sollecito were high on drink and cannabis and returned home after meeting Rudy Guede, the Ivory Coast drifter who was separately convicted of the killing.
Finding Miss Kercher at home alone, Knox decided to take revenge against her housemate whom she had come to view as boring and sober-minded.
Maybe the spark was an argument about Knox bringing home another man, or maybe about some missing money. No one knows for sure. But it is claimed that when Guede went to the bathroom, Knox and Sollecito started to argue with Miss Kercher in her room.
Venting her resentment of Miss Kercher, Knox pushed her violently against a cupboard while her boyfriend held her hair. Guede emerged from the bathroom and joined in, eager to compete with Sollecito to have sex with Miss Kercher.
When she fell to the ground the three tried to undress her, Knox pulling out a knife while Guede began to sexually abuse her.
Mr Mignini told the jury: 'It is easy to believe Knox said . . . "You were such a little saint . . . now you are going to be forced to have sex".'
As Sollecito pulled at her bra strap, Knox stabbed her for the first time. Pulling out his own, smaller knife, Sollecito did the same. As it became clear Miss Kercher would not submit, Knox began to strangle her as Sollecito continued to stab her, prompting Meredith to let out the 'terrible' scream that neighbour Nara Capezzali heard.
At this point, Knox delivered the fatal blow, plunging her knife into Miss Kercher's neck at around 11.30pm.
Under Italian law, relatives of victims can ask for compensation from the defendants if a guilty verdict is reached. Miss Kercher's family have lodged a claim for £22million damages for her death.
While the amount is largely symbolic, it is an additional front for Team Knox to fight. Mr Lumumba – later released without charge – has also put forward a compensation claim after what his lawyer called his 'ruthless defamation'.
He has said: 'My life as a man, husband and father has been ruined because of Amanda Knox.'
Then there is the separate case being brought by Italian police, also for defamation, over an interview given by Curt Knox and his ex-wife Edda to the Sunday Times in which they said their daughter had 'been abused physically and verbally' by police.
Team Knox has dismissed the possibility of such court action as a minor problem, adding that all their efforts will focus on clearing the name of Amanda.
Plans for her home-coming will not be cancelled, they say. Just put on hold. Whether that postponement will be a matter of months – or years – only time will tell.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1233399/Amanda-Knox-Behind-Hollywood-smile-liar-narcissist-killer.html#ixzz1ZNCazSER
